+1 415 842 4822 mail@channelmeister.com

Doomsday: the incentive perspective – The Daily PPILL #289

Alright. So a couple of days ago I got a little railed up and got carried away. I think that I did capture what I intuitively felt, my gut feeling. The analysis came shortly after the blog post was already published. This is not uncommon in me, to let my intuition guide me, but find an analytical justification.

So what is THIS article about? Well, I have been hearing doomsday scenarios about the eventual destruction of humanity because of the emergence of a superior artificial intelligence and I wanted to weigh them out. I just saw one a couple of days ago that was illustrated with this less-than-hopeful chart:

No bueno. Droves of hungry people on the streets. Revolutions. And at minimum a toilet paper run.

Now, there is not a single scenario out there. All of them are some version of a dystopian future, but with important differences. Three of them are notable to point out (the names are my own):

  • KingAI: AI is sponsored by a government, and we all become slaves of it.
  • Robber Baron AI: AI is sponsored by a corporation, and we all become mindless consumers of what it produces.
  • 2001 HAL AI: AI goes runaway, and tries to wipe out the human race because of some unintended algorithmic convergence.

And I am adding a fourth one:

  • Bored AI: Humans become pets.

Each of these assumes that the human race will play a different “role”. So for the first two ones, the human race has to become either a subject, or a consumer.

For the first scenario, if we assume that our new machine overlords can do EVERYTHING better than a person (this would include your job, and mine, my Uber Eats drivers’, Doña Juanita’s tortillas, and even your personal trainer), then what does an AI need us for? What does it need subjects for? Technically -in this scenario- we cannot “serve” it, because other AIs and Robots can do it better, cheaper, faster. The same goes if the AI is under the control of some individual or secret cabal (had to drop that in, for virality). Because of this, there is no incentive to build an AI that turns us into its subjects.

For the second scenario, let’s assume that the AI is developed by some evil corporation. They will want us to buy their services and goods, which they can do better, cheaper, faster. But sorry AI, we have no jobs, cannot buy squat. Again, there is no incentive to build an AI that turns us into mindless consumers.

Let’s talk about the last one and we will address evil, morally confused AI last. The scenario of becoming “pets” may seem the least harmful. So this works out to something that some people have proposed. We create so much resources and abundance, that people don’t need to work, and the AI can provide us with some form of universal basic income (a salary that we don’t have to work for) or some version of bottomless soup bowl and infinite refills of your favorite beverage (unlimited Latte refills appeals even to me!). We eventually become pets. Yes, we jut hang around, eat, sleep, and yes, go for walks, but the problem here is that us humans would be terrible at this. We are not particularly cute, and don’t jump up like my dog does when she sees me, regardless of what she was doing. I mean, I can get home at two AM, she may be sleeping, and she greets me as effusively as when I walk in through the door on a Friday afternoon. I cannot imagine a human doing that. Maybe a roll-over, but not that. So again, no incentive to turn us into pets.

The runaway AI is a risk, but we are assuming they will eventually become smarter than our own collective, and they will -to some extent- be our “offspring”. I don’t have an incentive-based answer for this, as this will come down to a moral and values-based decision that the AI will take. The best answer I have for this is the following: first, we need several independent AIs. Cannot allow everything to be concentrated in one single entity, and also, belligerent countries may find a special advantage if they develop an AGI faster. But in addition to this, the answer is not in restricting the AI, but in the training. David Deutsch is clear on this one:

“The way you prevent a child from becoming a new Hitler is just to explain to them why Hitler’s ideas were bad. It’s not really controversial that they are bad, and therefore it’s really very perverse to think that the only way we can stop an AGI from becoming a Hitler is to cripple it. By the way, I don’t think such crippling is possible.”

Going back to the incentives conversation. I don’t have clarity around how the future will look like exactly, but I know that the doomsday scenarios are not likely, because the incentives don’t align. Something tells me that the most likely scenario will be one of abundance, empowerment of every human being, and generation of new value. There are still lots of things that have to play out.

As originally published at The ChannelMeister
on April 13, 2023. Please consider sharing and subscribing HERE.
The Daily PPILL is my personal daily blog project. PPILL stands for Purpose, Process, Innovation, Leverage, and Leadership; the themes that I write about, and in my view, indispensable ingredients of any great initiative.

Huba Rostonics is a GTM and Business Strategy expert, offering services to Mid-Market, Enterprise, and Start-Ups. To learn more please schedule an exploratory call

Subscribe to The Daily PPILL

Sign up to get the very next Daily PPILL from The Channelmeister

Please wait...

Thank you!

You have successfully joined the subscriber list.

Whitelist mail@channelmeister.com and if you are using gmail, move my next email to "Primary" to ensure delivery.

The Unstoppable Force: Momentum – The Daily PPILL #329

In a world where technology is constantly advancing, simple yet ingenious inventions can capture our attention. The humble flywheel, often overlooked, these rotating wonders possess an appeal that inspires me, especially now that I am more and more involved with the creation of Exponential Organizations and the exponential technologies that are...

The time for ideas – The Daily PPILL #328

"An idea ahead of its time" Bet you heard that before. I have not only heard about it, I have lived through these, at least a couple of times trying to be way too cute and not getting the timing right. Just two examples: wanting to can coconut water in 1989, or starting a food delivery platform over the Internet in 2002. How to know? When is an...

Reimagining the Third Place: The Dynamics of Home, Work, and Escapes – The Daily PPILL #327

I bet you heard about "The Third Place". The concept was more in the popular media once Starbucks started to talk about it. If you have never heard about it, your first place is your home, your second place is work, and then we all have this need to escape somewhere else, that's the third place. I've been riding this pony since the 2000's, when...

The balancing act of freedom and accuracy in the Digital Age – The Daily PPILL #326

We love to demonize the press. The "mainstream media". They are out to manipulate us. Some of the more extreme argue that we should just get all our news and information (and therefore facts) from the uncensored, uncurated social media platforms, like Twitter. "Straight from the horse's mouth". I cannot say that there isn't a piece of this...

Finding Momentum in Resistance – The Daily PPILL #325

We need some resistance. I do. Nowhere is this more palpable than when you are in the water. You can feel the water pushing against you as you move. And that is a good thing, because paddling, pushing the water away from you, is what propels us forward. There is also our own awareness of that resistance, which lets us know that what we are doing...

Back of the envelope calculations – The Daily PPILL #324

You don't need to go deeply into differential calculus or any heavy math to apply one of the Enrico Fermi's most known techniques. Fermi gave us the first nuclear reactor and studied cosmic radiation and spiral galaxies. But the one thing that Fermi gave us that we can use every day is what is called a "Fermi Calculation". Probably not "invented"...

The Digital Revolution, are we there yet? – The Daily PPILL #323

We are still in the middle of one of the biggest transformations in humanity. I am thinking digitization. Sure, there are many others that are happening simultaneously and digitization started a while ago. That's how innovation works, with "nested S curves" whose effect aggregates and produces the exponentials we are experiencing. Digitization...

Against the current: The unintended consequences of change – The Daily PPILL #322

There is always at least one path of least resistance. That is less effort than any other. Partner behavior, sales focus, water, tend to flow in that direction. Most times it is also correlated with the status quo, and with our comfort zones. When we seek to make change happen, to divert things from where they are to somewhere else, chances are...

From Mediocre to Memorable: Chasing Moments of Perfection in a World of Mediocrity – The Daily PPILL #321

Most of us don't live in the Médoc in France, nor have unlimited resources to throw at our cellar, much less walk around with our personal sommelier. In consequence, we order wine, or we open a bottle at home, and is not that good. It may be too sweet, or too tanic, and may mess up our GI tract. But we keep doing this over and over again. Why?...

Precipice or Summit: How success depends on perspective – The Daily PPILL #320

You are standing at the same place. It is what it is. You have bee hiking for the last four hours. One foot in front of the other. Negotiating the rocks, the roots. Turning each switchback in expectation of being closer to the summit. Just the occasional sip of water and the permeating aroma of the woods that make you forget how tired you are....

Beyond Look and Feel: The User Interface is Key to Success – The Daily PPILL #319

"That's just look and feel" The "real" thing is what's running behind it. Or so they say. I you subscribe to thins thinking, you may be missing a fundamental fact. User Interface, or where people interact with something, is where adoption lives, and is the doorway to exponential growth. If people don't enjoy using something, they may use it a few...

Overriding the AI – The Daily PPILL #318

With all the talk about regulating AI, we hear the extremes coming to light. You have those that think we should just let everything run its course, and then there are some that think that we need a "kill switch". Others believe we need to have a human in the loop always. In many ways, this approach seems reasonable at first, but it defeats the...

The big ideas of 2020, three years later – The Daily PPILL #317

Looking back into how we imagined the future can be fascinating. We have all snickered when watching the Jetsons and we have turned "where's my jet pack" into kind of a critique of predictions in general. THIS ARTICLE was a featured article on LinkedIn in December 2019, and we all know what happened after that. We experienced first-hand Mike...

The Power of Intent: How the Future shapes the present – The Daily PPILL #316

The usually accepted thinking, is that the past shapes our present. We look into history to understand who we are. We even have a maxim in digital communications that goes "the best prediction of the next sample, is the immediately prior one". All of these are logic and have elements of truth. However, if you want to change things, you have to...

There’s Chemistry – The Daily PPILL #315

When it comes to our Channel ecosystem, and in all honesty, pretty much everything else, we can take a lesson out of our chemistry course. My wife, who is a PhD in Biochemistry will roll her eyes if she reads this, but here I go: Size matters. When recruiting partners or interconnecting them in your ecosystem, the relative scale of each...

Flower Power – The Daily PPILL #314

My anniversary was a few days ago. Of course I did get a gift, and I did make a reservation for dinner. But on this day, I like to wake up my wife to the aroma of flowers, but I don't want the flowers to whither overnight, so I had to make a customary dash in the morning to the nearest spot where I could get flowers. On my way out, a clerk smiled...

Love (for the B-Listers) makes the world go ’round – The Daily PPILL #313

We live in a world of A-lists. It is very easy to hear it "straight from the horse's mouth". If a celebrity is on Twitter, or any other platform, we can just follow them, watch their videos on YouTube or perhaps buy their book. That is wonderful. There has never been as much quality (and crappy as well) and variety of information out there since...

Is anybody gullible who believes the AI? – The Daily PPILL #312

Ever since ChatGPT made release 3.5, there has been more and more interest, and all kinds of people have been giving it a go. But I have the sense that many of us have also taken the approach that at least I like to go with when meeting someone new. We have trusted it. We have assumed that its responses were accurate. We are so used to relying on...

Optimism: How positive thinking moves you towards your goals – The Daily PPILL #311

When we are optimistic, we are more likely to take risks and try new things. We are more likely to believe in ourselves and our abilities, and to take action towards our goals. We are also more likely to stay positive and resilient in the face of adversity. This is fundamentally important when getting ourselves into something hard. An optimistic...

Re-post: Habit, Process, or Ritual? – The Daily PPILL #310

According to OpenAI ChatGPT, a process is a series of steps or actions that are taken in order to achieve a particular result. It is a way of doing something, typically involving a number of separate stages, each of which contributes to the overall outcome. Processes can be simple or complex, and they can be carried out by individuals or by teams...

Re-post: Partner Programs as an extension of the Operating Model – The Daily PPILL #309

Most partner programs look alike, and some of them look like they would've been thrown together from whatever was available. But organizations that don’t place enough care in how they design their partner programs may be wasting a huge opportunity to create and lock-in value. One of the fundamental pillars of the strategy of an organization is...

Re-post: The one thing you should do today – The Daily PPILL #308

Before you do anything else, ask yourself: "What is the one thing that I can (and must) do today to get me closer to my goals?" If you do nothing else, do that one thing. It will be worth more, and you'll feel more satisfied than after a full day of nonsense and busyness.

Re-post: The flywheel – The Daily PPILL #307

So many models today include this concept, but what is a flywheel? IRL, it is a massive -like with a lot of mass- wheel that keeps turning. Every internal combustion engine has one, where its function is to smooth out the motion originating from the cylinders pushing one at a time. There are other applications where the energy storage of a...

Re-post: Change before change gets to you – The Daily PPILL #306

There is nothing worse than getting caught in something that you did not expect, that you did not prepare for. When you know something is coming, it allows you to build the necessary skills, strength, or resources to be in a better position. In addition, it also allows you to get out of other competing endeavors. So if that's settled, let's look...

Re-post: Determination – The Daily PPILL #305

If we don’t have the will, we’ll never get things done. We may never even get started. Hannibal (not the fictional serial killer of “Silence of the Lambs”, but the Carthaginian general), has been recognized as one of the greatest military strategists of all times. Among other things, he famously invaded Italy (and the Roman Republic) during the...
%d bloggers like this: